Saturday, June 9

Q: What's Black and White and Green All Over? A: Hybrid Police Cars in Ohio

When New York City Mayor Bloomberg announced last week that the Big Apple’s fleet of yellow cabs would be converted to all hybrid vehicles by 2012, it got us thinking about the possibilities for Geneva’s municipal fleet.

Hybrids are traditional looking cars that are powered by both a gasoline engine and an electric motor. They get excellent gas mileage and reduce greenhouse gas emissions, so they are both economical and environmentally friendly.

The Ford Motor Company has teamed up with the Cleveland, Ohio, and other, police departments on a “Hybrid Patrol” program using Mercury Mariner Hybrid cars to raise awareness of the possibilities for fuel savings among municipal fleets. Police cars typically spend a great deal of time idling and would be good candidates for fuel saving models. Seattle, WA police have started adding hybrid Ford Escapes and Toyota Camrys to their fleet.

Question is, would a hybrid modified law enforcement specs have the muscle it takes to get the job done?

A report comparing performance data of the Ford Interceptor and a hybrid car is available here.

We’re not convinced that green police cars are a viable option, but City Council is following the lead of the US Conference of Mayors, the National League of Cities, and the International City/County Managers Association in rethinking energy efficiency in all facets of the community. Not only is it environmentally responsible, but it's a matter of saving money on energy as well.

When it comes time to purchase new vehicles, there are likely some options that would be more fuel efficient. The city manager’s car, for example, doesn’t need to travel at 110 MPH, so we think a hybrid would do just fine.

Thursday, June 7

4256 Hits, 1 Error

Our May appearance on Ted Baker’s morning show is now available. It contains a factual error that we want to correct. 11 minutes into the interview, Augustine addresses the County Revolving Loan Fund and the cited problems involving loans to the Geneva IDA about the incubator building. It is during this discussion that a factual error was made.

Augustine stated, “[t]his is public money and there is a standard of accountability for that. So, when we see a document that says that no loan application was filed until two and a half months after the monies were dispersed, well, I’m sure that was done for expediency to help the businesses along, to serve some public purpose, but that doesn’t relieve anyone of the obligation of being the watchdogs of the public dollar. This is not monopoly money, this is tax money.”


In the interest of full disclosure, we wish to set the record straight on this matter. The Geneva IDA loan application was filed two and a half years after the money was dispersed. This was detailed in the list of loan irregularities that we posted
here .

Councilor D’Amico made a comment about Pete Rose. We weren’t sure how to interpret that reference, but we’re happy to report that we surpassed his career hit record (4,256) on June 2nd. We’re not gamblers, but with only one error so far, it looks like our credibility is a pretty safe bet.

Monday, June 4

City Manager Evaluation is Council's Primary Responsibility

The relationship between the City Council and the City Manager is often compared to the private sector, with the Council serving as a Board of Directors and the Manager as CEO. Whether you like this analogy or not, it is useful for highlighting the basic responsibility that each Councilor has to the people of the city—evaluating the Manager’s performance. Like a Board of Directors who must determine if the CEO has run the company in a way that protects the shareholder’s interests, the Manager’s annual performance evaluation is a means of communicating goals and priorities.

In the past, Council approached the evaluation process haphazardly. The results were not great, and the City Manager was not provided much in the way of meaningful feedback. However, in 2004, Council adopted a new strategy for evaluations, creating a form that better reflected the key responsibilities of the Manager’s position, and providing an opportunity for Council to take a more active role in goal-setting.

The evaluation is supposed to occur on or before the anniversary date of the City Manager’s contract, which is July 19th. The evaluation looks back on the prior calendar year’s activities and accomplishments, and makes a recommendation for a salary increase to be included in the following year’s budget. The timing is meant to allow Council adequate time to complete the evaluation (the first quarter); to negotiate with the City Manager (the second quarter); for the City Manager to include the agreed upon increase in his budget proposal (third quarter); and for Council to approve it (fourth quarter) before beginning the process again the following January.

Unfortunately, it has never once gone so smoothly. This all came to a head in early February, when council voted 5-4 to grant the City Manager a 5% retroactive increase without an evaluation having been completed (you can read the minutes here). It brought to light the need for Council to regroup and commit to bringing some integrity back to the process.

On February 21, Council met to reach agreement on the evaluation process. You can see it detailed here. One month later, in March (meeting minutes available here), the Mayor indicated that a meeting with the City Manager would finalize the evaluation form and the process would begin. You can view the finalized form here. The evaluation form was distributed in April to all councilors and was due to the Mayor (via the City Clerk’s office) on May 31st. We look forward to the next step, which should be a special meeting of Council to review the evaluations, the City Manager’s self-evaluation, and to work on producing the consensus document to present to the City Manager as the “Council evaluation.”