Saturday, June 23

Mayor's Comments Heavy on Emotion, Light on Fact

On Friday, the Mayor had a press conference and made some pointed comments about us. Craig Fox, of the Finger Lakes Times, asked us to respond.
Well, most of the things we had to say have already appeared here on the blog. That's the point: We express our opinions openly and stand by those statements.

On Thursday, June 14th we posted about our latest radio appearance. We received a question from someone wanting to know our thoughts on the Democratic Committee's endorsements. We responded, but maybe people haven't gotten the hang of exploring all the comments yet, so here is what we wrote:

For the most part, our blog leaves party politics to the City Republican and Democratic Committees, but, since you ask, we'll say this: In our view, the underlying causes of the current disharmony are the Mayor's lack of leadership, the City Manager's "divide and conquer" approach to relations with Council, and the Council's own impatience with dialogue and lack of interest in exploring issues from a variety of perspectives in full view of the public.

We agree that this is troubling, but if the alternative to this "division" is to roll over and just "go along to get along," then the division must stand regardless of how uncomfortable it may be. Our approach is to continue exploring issues, provide information and a point of view to the public and try and generate solutions to the real problems of local government.

As for endorsements, the City's Democratic and Republican committees have always been an important component of local government. Committee members, whose positions are actually public offices and who are therefore accountable to voters in their parties, are dedicated volunteers who work to frame issues and recruit candidates.

We think it perfectly reasonable for those committees to evaluate the public performance of Council and take that into account when making endorsements. And it's a two-way street. Councilors can disagree with the committees to the point where they are compelled to go their separate ways. In the recent round of endorsements, or lack there of, Mayor Cass and Councilors Greco and Cosentino actively sought the endorsement of the Democratic Committee. They interviewed just like we, and the other candidates, did. They heard the committee express its commitment to open, honest, transparent city government just like we did. They understood the committee's desire for candidates who would do their homework on critical issues and engage in respectful dialogue.

Cass and Greco were ultimately not endorsed. The Finger Lakes Times reported Cass and Greco's anger, but not the Committee's reasons for the decision. Cosentino was endorsed, but handed his endorsement back to the Committee. Again, the Times tried to portray his actions as a noble gesture of solidarity with Greco and Cass, but his letter to the editor states that he made a political calculation that it was against his "own best interest" to accept the endorsement. He's entitled to do that, too.

The Republican party has an equal responsibility to establish criteria and select candidates. So far we haven't heard what criteria they are interested in. Weeks ago, Mr. Beckley stated he considers himself the best person for the job of Mayor. That must mean that he believes he can manage Council better than Mayor Cass. But his past public comments and his numerous opinion pieces, as well as those of some of his running mates (including Councilor D'Amico) have wholeheartedly supported the current administration's operations. The Republicans will likely focus on the symptoms of the problem ('the division on council') rather than the root cause (a lack of leadership and good faith dealing on the part of the administration). With that, they probably hope to stay below the radar and not really take a position on anything of consequence.

Bottom line, our system leaves it up to the parties to field candidates that they believe will work together for the good of the city. Then its up to the registered voters of the City of Geneva to meet, question, and evaluate those candidates and cast their vote for the ones they want working for them.

Wednesday, June 20

If You Were the Mayor/ A Call for Reader Responses

During our most recent appearance on WGVA (available here), Ted Baker asked us “What would you do if you were mayor?” While we were quick to point out that neither one of us is interested in becoming mayor, we offered a few ideas of our own on solutions to the problems of local government in the City of Geneva.

For starters, we’d like Council to become a well prepared, highly informed, deeply engaged deliberative body, respectful of dialogue. In our view, it is up to the Mayor to facilitate the group. That would involve facing fears, moving forward with confidence, exercising strong leadership skills, and being well organized.

We’d also like to see the Mayor schedule more work sessions, such as the budget workshops held by City staff and Council in 2006, to allow close interaction between Councilors and City staff. People can roll up their sleeves, study the issues, and solve problems, with lots of interaction, and in a public way.

Another thing we might do is look at well-functioning government bodies to see if we can get ideas for improving our own operating system. We believe one of the reasons for the success of Ontario County Board of Supervisors and Canandaigua City Council is their committee system. Unfortunately, the Geneva City Charter frowns upon standing committees. The alternative, that we have right now, requires councilors to serve as a “jack of all trades” on issues from public safety to public works, debt service to recreation services. We know what the other half of that old cliché is, and we think it should be changed in the name of better government.

The buck should stop with the Mayor. The Mayor is the public leader, accountable to the voters, and ought to lead the Council in setting a course for the City. He is then responsible for giving direction to City staff, who are our career civil servants and government professionals.

Right now, we have an inversion, where city staff often sets the agenda for Council. Council is often in a reactive, rather than a pro-active mode. Whether you like the results or not, you can appreciate the problem of having non-elected people calling the shots. That needs to be the other way around and it is up to the Mayor to lead that effort.

Of course, we’d like more open discussion. Get things out of the back room and onto the Council floor. We shouldn’t worry about how much time that takes. If a proper discussion means two meetings each month, so be it. Council used to meet twice a month, until about 2005, and got a lot of business done, including the Hampton Inn, the Social Security Building, the Seneca Falls Savings Bank, and the Lyons National Bank

Lastly, the Mayor should foster a collaborative partnership between Council and the City Manager. There is an International City Manager’s Association of which our own manager is a member. They have a code of ethics that clearly specifies the role the Manager should play and how he should interact with his Council. The Mayor’s role is to ensure that these standards of professionalism are adhered to; that the City Manager deals with Council as a body rather than cultivating individualized personal relationships with councilors that lead to one-on-one deals being struck outside of the public meetings.

There’s much more to say, but that’s an overview of what we talked about with Ted Baker. We never have advance notice of the questions he’ll be posing to us, and the ideas we came up with in the interview were just our initial reaction to the question. But we realized, after the interview, that this is a great question to pose to the community at large. We’d now like to ask our readers the question Ted Baker asked us: “What would you do if you were Mayor?” Let us know .

Thursday, June 14

Radio Appearance Friday 8:35am on 1240 AM

We have a regularly scheduled radio appearance on the third Friday of each month. In June, that means its tomorrow!

It was a pleasant surprise to hear that, after our last appearance, there was a caller to the station who wanted to pose a question to us. Ted Baker is a great interviewer, posing pertinent questions and probing follow-ups, but he agrees that questions from other interested people are a good thing. The show is not set up to be a call-in session, but we encourage people to submit comments/questions/suggestions here and we'll see if we can work them into this or future shows.

Click below to add your thoughts.