On election night, five votes separated Ron Alcock and Chip Capraro on the machine counts. That result was affirmed by Republican Commissioner Mike Northrup after the post-election machine recanvassing. Those results are still posted on the Election Commission's website.
On Wednesday, November 14th, absentee and affidavit ballots were unsealed and counted. Capraro won that count by a large enough margin to swing the results in his favor, but Northrup emerged from a side room to announce that a 'clerical error' had widened the margin between the candidates and Capraro was actually down nine votes.
In other races in our area, where margins were even wider, candidates have initiated the process of serving papers to impound the machines, recount the ballots, and have a clear explanation of the outcome to be certified by the Board. In keeping with that standard procedure, Democratic Election Commissioner Mary Salotti and her Republican counterpart, Mike Northrup, were served with papers, Wednesday, November 28th.
The documents, prepared by local attorney Sam Bonney, petition that the commissioners not certify the election "until machines used in Ward 4 District 1 are tested and examined per Election Law 9-208 and an explanation in writing is made about the discrepancies in the machine vote."
The petition is supported by three affidavits submitted by voters who describe difficulties in pulling the levers on Row A on a malfunctioning machine that was eventually taken out of service. Complaints were made to poll workers on election day, by two voters over three hours apart. At least 50 voters used that machine between the first and second complaints.
In addition to clarification on the nature of the clerical errors, the petition proposes that there be "both statutory and diagnostic testing, to determine the specific malfunction of the machines."
In previous statements, Northrup said the election would be certified by Monday, December 3rd. Does this mean that these questions will be left unanswered?
Thursday, November 29
Will Candidates Get Answers Before Election is Certified?
Posted by
Capraro and Augustine
at
11:33 PM
0
responses
Wednesday, November 28
Public Involvement in Choosing a Public Leader? This Novel Concept is Stranger than Fiction
Springfield, Missouri finds itself in a situation similar to ours. Their city manager has given notice that he will be leaving in 2008. But, in a strange twist, their outgoing mayor is not rushing to appoint a committee of political insiders, but is instead inviting the public to sign up to serve. Say what?
Eight years ago Geneva had its own citizen’s committee to select a city manager. Twenty four residents from across the community spent countless hours reading, evaluating, and discussing resumes from candidates coming from all over the United States. The committee, which Capraro served on, conducted phone interviews to narrow down the candidates to three top finalists. Every member of the committee agreed that the three finalists brought the experience, expertise, and commitment to become part of the community that we need in a city manager.
City council took the three names, thanked the committee for their work, and then proceeded to hire Rich Rising, who was not amongst the committee’s finalists. So much for valuing the input of the community.
With his term rapidly drawing to a close, we suspect that Mayor Cass might want to repeat this process as his last official action. Hopefully, that will not happen.
The people of Geneva have the talent, the energy, and the time to make this selection the right way. And they should not feel rushed to do so. The City Manager is the Chief Administrative Officer for the city. That means he oversees the day to day tasks that support City Council’s established policies. But that does not mean that the city will perish if the post sits vacant for a few months. We have skilled department heads who are fully capable of managing operations for a short transition period. What is most important in the selection of a new manager is that we get a candidate with the skills, integrity, and vision to build upon Geneva’s strengths and to tackle our challenges head on.
Manufacturing is not a silver bullet for Upstate New York anymore. So those who said we need a manager who can “get another Guardian” are, in our opinion, a bit misguided. We need to reverse our population decline, boost our tourism appeal, and provide better, more targeted city services to residents as a return on their tax investment. Speaking of taxes, we need a manager who understands that the average homeowner is having trouble keeping up with the tax bill.
The best way to get a Manager that can connect with the needs and interests of the people is to have the people involved in selecting the Manager.
Enter Springfield. Because their Mayor is at the end of his term, a current councilor (Gary Deaver) is chairing the search committee, but there is no indication that he is trying to impose his own views on the community. Instead, he tells a local newspaper:
“This will be one of the most important decisions the council makes in quite some time.. It’s my goal to create a process that is totally transparent and inclusive.”
That process begins with a new Web site– which the city planned to unveil last week – where citizens can fill out a questionnaire and offer comments about what characteristics are most important for a city manager. Linked to the city’s home page, www.springfieldmo.gov, citizens also will be able to fill out a volunteer application if they are interested in serving on the search committee.
The voters brought Stu Einstein into city hall because they responded to his promise of a new way of doing business. The search for a new city administrator is the best way to show a commitment to bringing new people, new faces, new voices to the table. We hope that outgoing Mayor Cass will not take advantage of incoming Mayor Einstein's good nature and stick him with the dilemma of either accepting an aggressive move to control the City Manager search process as a lame duck or protesting it and risking being labeled vindictive. The new mayor should get the same break as the old mayor: a fresh start with a new city manager.
Posted by
Capraro and Augustine
at
5:02 PM
0
responses
Tuesday, November 27
Does Gundersen Have the Prescription for Geneva?
We hope you were able to watch the unprecedented statewide interactive forum with Economic Development czar Dan Gundersen that we posted an alert about. The show, aired on PBS stations was called “Upstate: Getting Down to Business.”
It was an incredibly informative discussion of the challenges and opportunities present throughout upstate communities and it resonated with several local issues we’ve been discussing here. You may remember when we first discussed Governor Spitzer’s appointment of Gundersen as the point person for upstate economic development (read it here). Well, he has gotten right to work developing ‘targeted economic development plans’ for several communities, from Buffalo to Rochester to Syracuse to Binghamton. While the show discussed these a bit, the majority of time was spent focusing on the shared concerns of municipalities struggling to retain existing businesses, attract new businesses and residents and generally revive their economies.
Gundersen and his Acting Regional Director, Kevin Hurley, outlined three “barriers to development” that need to be the focus of local, state, and federal economic development efforts. The three are:
- High Taxes. As Peter Alan Weinman stated, in his opening comments to Gundersen on behalf of the City of Buffalo, “property taxes are growing at an alarming pace” and Buffalo has one of the highest rates in Western NY (you can compare their rate of $37.41/ $1000 assessed value to our rate by clicking here). Gundersen spoke frequently of the Commission on Local Government Efficiency as an agency that is examining this issue in close detail. You can visit the Commission here and see how ideas like shared services (that we discuss in relation to Geneva here) and parity in compensation (that we discuss in relation to sewer services here) are key to alleviating the tax burden that scares away businesses and residents.
- A Lack of Young Professionals. Maybe you’ve heard it referred to as the “brain drain” but that might not exactly capture it. Recent college graduates and other young professionals are not only looking for employment opportunities, but for a certain community or social dynamic. Better collaboration between area employers, colleges, and government leaders might enhance those offerings in Geneva. For our take on attracting young families to the area, see “Rethinking City Living."
- Dwindling Downtowns. It’s not just young professionals, but many potential new residents that are looking for vibrant downtowns. The work-downstairs, live-upstairs model is once again gaining ground and communities that want to revitalize need to focus on repopulating their downtown areas with shops, restaurants, and cultural offerings and housing for the people who can frequent these establishments. This is the focus of the recent RESTORE NY application submitted by the city.
Posted by
Capraro and Augustine
at
12:17 PM
2
responses