Thursday, February 25, the Finger Lakes Community College Projects Committee, which is chaired by County Supervisor Richard Calabrese (R-Gorham) and includes Geneva City Supervisor Rocky LaRocca, and additional Supervisors and members of the FLCC staff and Board of Trustees, met to discuss public presentations regarding the proposed Geneva Extension Center.
To kick off the meeting, JMZ Architects and Planners provided a viewing of their PowerPoint presentation which explores various options for a new extension center. The County currently leases classroom space in the building which formerly housed the Geneva Middle School, at the corner of Milton and Pulteney Streets in the City of Geneva. Purchasing and renovating that building was one of three options considered initially for the new center.
At Thursday's meeting, JMZ stated unequivocally that the main structure at that site-- the 1926 structure originally built to house Geneva High-- is structurally sound. The 1965 natatorium and gymnasium additions have not fared as well. They, apparently, were built without expansion joints and as a result of a lack of maintenance, have deteriorated. Under every option proposed, that wing (facing Pulteney and William Streets) is recommended for demolition.
Reuse of the main structure was the least costly of the three initial options presented. The estimated cost of renovation-- $18 million-- did exceed the $12 million budget, but would make available 90,000 square feet of renovated space. FLCC currently utilizes 80,000 square feet within the building, but a revised space assessment had come in at 58,000 square feet. Full renovation would leave 32,000 square feet open for use by potential co-tenants. But the Projects Committee Chairman ruled that Thursday's meeting was not the time or place to examine issues of co-tenancy, layout and contracting options and the minutia of each plan. Instead, he opened the floor to questions from non-committee members which were recorded by the clerk and made part of the official record. Chairman Calabrese assured everyone present that written responses would be provided for every question submitted on the record.
Here are the comments and questions put to the Committee on Thursday:
1) The Geneva City Councilors who had penned a defense of the County's process the day before in the local paper, Ron Alcock and Paul D'Amico, were in attendance, as was Councilor Augustine. D'Amico did not ask questions, but simply repeated his support for demolishing the main building at Milton and Pulteney and building new. Alcock noted the need for the community to be notified of, and perhaps involved in, the design process for any new building, to foster clear communication on issues such as set backs from the street and the overall orientation of the building within the neighborhood.
2) City resident and member of the FLCC Foundation Board, George Michaels, asked for more detailed analysis of the space needs. He pointed out that the $11.9 million plan that includes demolition of the building and construction of a new space would result in far less than the 58,000 square feet that FLCC said it needs. He received an immediate response from the architect, who stated that the orientation of the new building on the site allows for further additions and expansion in the out years. Michaels responded that he would prefer to see the money spent to accommodate current needs stemming from recent growth and anticipated needs from projected future growth. He noted a 28% increase in student enrollment at the Geneva center within the past year. He asked again for a detailed analysis of those projections as they related to space needs and square footage costs under each option.
3) Pulteney Street resident Diana Davis asked about the practices for estimating particular line item costs, and in particular, the nearly $900,000 projected to improve the parking lot at the corner of Pulteney and William Street.
4) Augustine submitted six questions/requests for information for the record, three directed at the architects and three at the committee as a whole.
From the architects, she asked for the following:
1. A timeline for the project, if approved, including phasing of the construction and demolition elements. An assurance that the full range of classes would continue to be available at the extension center site while the project proceeds.
2. A clarification on the cost estimates per square foot for the $18 million project that puts FLCC classroom space on all three floors.
3. The estimated process timeline for SHPO sign off for the draw down of state funds for a project option that includes demolition.
From the Committee as a whole, she asked for the following:
1. A detailed description of the process of considering and rejecting each of various co-tenancy options for the renovated main building. This a follow up to an assurance made by President Risser at a 2008 City Council meeting, that the committee along with the Community Advisory Committee, would look at co-tenancy options.
2. (Similar to Mr. Michaels' request), the five-year growth projections (both in programming and enrollment) for the Geneva Extension and the associated space needs.
3. Results of focus studies and/or other research that indicate that a flat-roof, contemporary building design is needed to achieve the "message of hope" that President Risser says that the building must convey to students. This is in contrast to other college improvement projects that opt for a more traditional collegiate design that might be more in line with the existing neighborhood.
We assume the FLCC Projects committee is already hard at work developing responses to the questions posed and will conduct public meetings (TBD) to receive input on the plans before a decision is made, beginning with a presentation to the Geneva City Council (TBD). While Chairman Calabrese said that he didn't want to give any "false hope" that the committee would step back and reconsider demolition, we do remain confident that an honest and open public process will bring forward the public intelligence that will ensure the best decision for the long term needs of the County, the college, and the Geneva community.
Monday, March 8
FLCC Projects Committee Wants Questions on Proposed Geneva Extension Center:
We Want Answers
Posted by
Capraro and Augustine
at
11:58 PM
0
responses
Thursday, February 18
BS (as in Bait and Switch) Part II:
Wonderful Bait for a Sinister Switch
On March 29, 2009, NY State Senator Mike Nozzolio’s website read “Senator Nozzolio Delivers!” What was it that he was delivering? Over $26 million in State dollars for projects bundled as the “21st Century Geneva Plan”-- and what turned out to be lots of bait for local practitioners of bait and switch.
$5 million of the bundle was dedicated to a “signature building for the Finger Lakes region that will serve as a destination for tourists.” That building, it was eventually determined by City Council, would be the Finger Lakes Boating Museum, currently operating out of meager facilities in Penn Yan.
$6 million was earmarked to match $6 in funding the Ontario County board of supervisors had already set aside for the “Finger Lakes Community College Campus in Geneva.” The Geneva FLCC campus had been housed for many years at the “Civic Center” and, in 2006, was moved to the former Geneva Middle School building at the corner of Pulteney and Milton Streets, leased to Ontario County by the Geneva City School District.
At first, taxpayers seemed generally pleased with the use of their state dollars in these ways. State money, it appeared, was being used to support placement of a regional tourist attraction, the Boating Museum, on the lakefront. And the new structure would be an architecturally significant building replacing the drab City building which currently houses the Chamber of Commerce.
Recall how the current building, which formerly housed the local Boy Scouts Council, was put on that site without proper footings. Over time, revenue from the lease with the Chamber for the use of interior fell short of expenses for the upkeep of the exterior. The building, of no historical significance, has been generally accepted as an eyesore on the lakefront and might be better used as a source of recycled building materials.
In September 2009, the City Council agreed with the Finger Lakes Boating Museum (FLBM) to design and build a more appropriate facility to house the Chamber and to serve as a regional tourist destination. However, as that project appears to move forward, the money Nozzolio promised seems to move back to Albany.
Nozzolio had come up with the $5 million figure by securing $4 million from the NYS Dormitory Authority and keeping his fingers crossed for another $1 million from a specific source he has yet to identify. The Senator’s office still has not been able to tell reporters from the local paper where the other $1 million resides.
In addition, it seems, Nozzolio’s priority has shifted from a regional destination to a local office complex. Rather than clearly backing the boating museum concept, the $4 million seems now to be flagged for new-and-improved offices to be occupied by the Geneva Area Chamber of Commerce (GACC).
If that is the case, Geneva City taxpayers would lose out doubly. While both the GACC and FLBM are tax-exempt entities, the FLBM is a regional destination, a place that people living here or visiting would come to experience. So, not only would the upgraded deluxe Chamber of Commerce not house activities that local residents could participate in, it would also eliminate another activity that would presumably draw tourists Geneva to boost the economy.
It is also worth noting that the notorious Bergmann report of 2009 on downtown-lakefront connectivity emphasizes the need to pursue water-related uses on the lakefront as a maximization of the highly coveted land that currently belongs to all of Geneva’s citizens. A Chamber of Commerce executive suite hardly seems water-based or even water-related. A boating museum and the proposed enhanced dockage fits the vision perfectly.
In the case of the FLCC extension center, use of the former Geneva Middle School building has accomplished many community goals. First, it stabilized a building that has significant community value and is eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic places along with its neighboring church and church school.
Second, it keeps FLCC students near the city center, utilizing its optimal location both to benefit students looking for a convenient location and downtown businesses happy to have more patrons in the vicinity. Last, it assisted the Geneva City School District in putting to good use a building that was no longer serving the district but still in need of maintenance.
But wait. A memo from FLCC president, Barb Risser, states her preference to tear down the building and looking forward “to the day a couple of years from now when we will open a… modern campus center in Geneva." So those two $6 million amounts, $12million total, which is nothing more than a combination of county tax and state tax dollars, will be used to pay Casella to take tons of building debris and then to build a smaller more contemporary looking building in its place.
Bait and switch takes many forms. In this instance, what’s used as the ‘bait’ are the community’s own values and ideas. Then, once the tax dollars are appropriated, under the guise of the public good in the public interest, the ‘switch’ comes in and we end up with projects that not only don’t achieve the intended outcome, but actually work against it.
Foregoing a boating museum for a Chamber office takes up valuable lakefront space for an unnecessary purpose. Foregoing a building renovation for contemporary new construction destroys a valuable piece of the community fabric and dumps a costly, unsightly single-purpose structure in its place. In both cases, what is unique about Geneva is used as leverage to get money for projects that ultimately destroy that very character.
Posted by
Capraro and Augustine
at
10:32 PM
0
responses
Sunday, January 31
Is the Red and Black In the Red or in the Black?
City Schools Seek $12.5 million in New Borrowing
A year ago, we ran a series of posts concerning the Geneva City School District's proposal to shift from two K-5 neighborhood schools to one primary (PreK-2) and one intermediate (3-5) school. The plan was brought to our attention by faculty and staff who were concerned that the effort was misguided in several ways. We don’t deal in leaks and rumors, so we didn’t post until we’d checked out the facts. And when we did, we were compelled to speak out about what we’d found, especially when the Finger Lakes Times was giving the plan a pass.
First, we shared worries that the plan was educationally unsound, and that it was likely to lead to greater disassociation between students, parents, and their school. Second, it was foreseen that there were serious logistical difficulties with such a move: scheduling, bussing, and adequate classroom space would be a problem.
Underlying those concerns, and creating a situation of distrust within which those issues could not easily be discussed or addressed, was the perception that the District administration, in conjunction with favored insider faculty members, was moving full steam ahead in insulated, secretive, non-public meetings.
Sure enough, the Finger Lakes Times towed the "company line" that no decisions had been made and there were no foregone conclusions. But they didn't press, and they didn't ask the hard follow up questions that would have revealed the facts behind the well-controlled sound bites. Despite the newspaper's headline "Nothing Decided" (2/9/09), the final public hearing on the proposal was held March 25th, and the decision passed with the support of five of the seven school board members on April 6th.
In less than two months, the District maintained (according to the resolution that you can read here) "the reconfiguration of the elementary schools will maintain and/or enhance the quality of educational programming for students and will also maintain fiscal discipline during this time of economic uncertainty."
You might wonder, as we do: Has the reconfiguration of the elementary schools enhanced, or at least maintained, the quality of educational programming for students? Did the move maintain "fiscal discipline" during a time of economic uncertainty? While we abhor the concept, we wonder if at least the ends justified the means? Did the perceived Machiavellian maneuvers of the District administration at least pan out?
If so, you wouldn’t think this move would require, in its first year, the pursuit of a $12.5million building project to remedy a lack of classroom space that, apparently, went unnoticed or unplanned for during the very process that the District said was guided by a thorough, responsible, and detail-oriented advisory committee. We wish it was otherwise, but alas, the district is putting just such a request up for a public referendum on March 9, 2010 (one year and one month, to the day, after solemn reassurance to District families and taxpayers public that this wasn’t a ‘done deal’).
Here’s the referendum item:
SPECIAL REFERENDUM
SPECIAL REFERENDUM OF THE QUALIFIED VOTERS OF
GENEVA CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that a special referendum of the qualified voters of the City School District of the City of Geneva, New York, shall be held at Geneva High School, 101 Carter Road, Geneva, New York on Tuesday, March 9, 2010, between the hours of 12:00 o’clock to 9:00 P.M., for the purpose of voting on the following proposition:
PROPOSITION
SHALL THE BOND RESOLUTION ADOPTED BY THE BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE CITY OF GENEVA, NEW YORK, DATED JANUARY 19, 2010, AUTHORIZING CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS CONSISTING OF ADDITION TO, CONSTRUCTION AND RECONSTRUCTION OF, SCHOOL BUILDINGS AND FACILITIES, VARIOUS SITE IMPROVEMENTS, AND THE ACQUISITION OF CERTAIN ORIGINAL FURNISHINGS, EQUIPMENT, AND APPARATUS AND OTHER INCIDENTAL IMPROVEMENTS REQUIRED IN CONNECTION THEREWITH FOR SUCH CONSTRUCTION AND SCHOOL USE, AT AN ESTIMATED MAXIMUM AGGREGATE COST OF $12,500,000; AND PROVIDING THAT SUCH COSTS SHALL BE RAISED BY THE LEVY OF A TAX TO BE COLLECTED IN ANNUAL INSTALLMENTS WITH SUCH TAX TO BE OFFSET BY STATE AID AVAILABLE THEREFOR, AND IN ANTICIPATION OF SUCH TAX, DEBT OBLIGATIONS OF THE SCHOOL DISTRICT AS MAY BE NECESSARY, NOT TO EXCEED SUCH ESTIMATED MAXIMUM AGGREGATE COST, SHALL BE ISSUED, AND, IF THE PROPOSITION FOR THE APPROVAL OF SUCH BOND RESOLUTION SHALL HAVE BEEN APPROVED BY AT LEAST A SIXTY PERCENT VOTE, SUCH OBLIGATIONS MAY BE ISSUED IN EXCESS OF THE CONSTITUTIONAL DEBT LIMIT OF THE SCHOOL DISTRICT PURSUANT TO APPLICABLE LAW, ALL BE APPROVED?”
For the complete referendum, click here.
It's probably wise for the Board of Education to separate the vote for $12.5million of new debt from the May vote for the election of new Board members. Is it to cover their lack of foresight—or, the old bait and switch? Whether it was poor planning or misleading the public, or something else, perhaps board members feared that residents who care about accountability and fiscal responsibility would not re-elect board members who supported this ill-fated reconfiguration.
In upcoming posts we will delve into this issue in more detail, fully presenting this case study of bait and switch. But we are again reminded that one of the values in public, inclusive decision-making processes (which the reconfiguration debacle certainly was not) is the ability of governing board to be clued in to 'public intelligence' on critical issues. We see what happens when those in power think they know better than those they are elected to represent. Unfortunately, it's the represented that end up footing the bill for their representatives’ mistakes.
Posted by
Capraro and Augustine
at
9:56 PM
0
responses